Request an audit

Field notes

Top Three on Google Maps. Missing From ChatGPT.

A new study of 200,000 local searches found Google Maps named a business twice as often as ChatGPT did. Here's why doing well on Maps doesn't carry over.

Auto shop not showing up in ChatGPT? A new study of 200,000 local searches shows Google Maps and AI keep different scoreboards.

Key takeaways

  • In a September 2026 BrightLocal study, Google Maps named the business being tracked in 66% of searches. ChatGPT named it in 33%.
  • Ask ChatGPT the same local question twice and you'll usually get a different list.
  • Your Google work isn't wasted. It just doesn't carry over to AI on its own.

Picture a shop owner who figures he's fine on AI because he's in the top three on Google Maps. Great reviews. Busy bays.

Then he asks ChatGPT where to get brakes done in his own town. His shop isn't in the answer.

If your auto shop is not showing up in ChatGPT, it probably isn't because you did something wrong on Google. AI keeps a different scoreboard. And now there's real data on how different.

What 200,000 Local Searches Showed

In September, BrightLocal published a study of about 200,000 local searches. They ran them over 60 days for about 1,300 businesses on ChatGPT, Google's AI Mode and Google's AI Overviews.

One note up front: BrightLocal sells a tool that tracks this, so they have a stake in it. The numbers are still worth a look.

In BrightLocal's study, Google Maps named the business being tracked in 66% of searches. ChatGPT named it in 33%. AI Mode named it in 32%.

Maps named it twice as often as ChatGPT did.

Big brands aren't immune either. Earlier this year, SOCi's 2026 Local Visibility Index looked at more than 350,000 locations of 2,751 brands that run many locations. As Localogy reported, ChatGPT suggested just 1.2% of those locations. Those locations showed up in Google's top three map results 35.9% of the time, on average.

Those are companies with marketing departments. Their Google results didn't carry over either.

Google Maps vs. ChatGPT, Side by Side

From BrightLocal's study (Sept 2026)Google MapsChatGPTGoogle AI ModeAI Overviews
Named the business being tracked66%33%32%38%
How much the list overlaps when the search is repeatedNot reported this way23%21%33%
How much the list overlaps from different spots in one townNot reported this way36%47%47%

Winning on Maps gets you a seat at Google's table. AI sets its own table.

Ask Twice, Get a Different List

This is the part that matters most.

BrightLocal ran the same searches more than once. On ChatGPT, the lists overlapped by only 23% from one try to the next. A business that showed up once came back in about half of the later tries.

Move across town and it shifts again. On ChatGPT, lists from different spots in the same town overlapped by only about a third.

So if you asked ChatGPT once, from your office, and saw your name, congratulations. That's one answer. Your customer across town may have gotten a different one this morning.

You can't check this once and call it done. Your customers aren't asking once, either.

Why Your Shop Isn't Showing Up in ChatGPT

For years, winning on Google meant working your Google Business Profile. Photos, hours, reviews, posts. You probably did that, and it shows.

Here's the catch. BrightLocal found Google Business Profile matters for Google's own AI answers, but it's "hardly used by ChatGPT."

The thing you worked hardest on is the thing ChatGPT looks at least.

AI assistants pull from many places and cite them. In BrightLocal's study, business websites made up 42% of everything AI cited. Directories like Yelp made up a smaller share.

The details aren't always right, either. SOCi found AI answers getting basics like hours and addresses wrong, especially on ChatGPT and Perplexity, as Localogy reported.

And if you run a mobile detailing or mobile repair business with no storefront, it's a little harder still. BrightLocal found businesses with a storefront were mentioned 33.6% of the time. Businesses that go to the customer were mentioned 29.4% of the time.

That's why a monthly Google report can look great while AI skips you. It's measuring Google. AI isn't Google.

What to Check This Week

You don't need a new vendor to see where you stand. You need ten minutes and a notepad.

Ask ChatGPT the questions drivers ask when they need a shop. "Who's good for brakes in [your town]?" "Where should I take my truck for a check engine light?" Ask each one a few times. Ask from the shop and from home. Write down every shop it names.

It won't be a measurement. But it'll tell you fast whether this is your problem. (I walk through how to make sense of what you see in What Does AI Say About Your Auto Shop?.)

I spent years around auto repair shops and their data. Google Maps took owners years to win, and nobody told them a second scoreboard had opened. The shop down the street might not be better than you. AI just keeps naming him.

Questions Shop Owners Ask

If I'm in the top three on Google Maps, will ChatGPT recommend me?
Not necessarily. In BrightLocal's 2026 study, Google Maps named the tracked business in 66% of searches and ChatGPT in 33%. Doing well on Maps helps on Google. It doesn't guarantee a spot in AI answers.

Why does ChatGPT give a different answer every time I ask?
AI answers move around. BrightLocal found ChatGPT's lists overlapped by only 23% when the same search was repeated. Where the driver is in town changes the answer too.

Where does AI get its information about my shop?
From many places it can find online. In BrightLocal's study, business websites were the biggest group, at 42% of everything AI cited. The same study found ChatGPT hardly uses Google Business Profile, even though Google's own AI answers do.


Spilld asks AI the questions drivers actually ask, again and again, with and without searching the web. Then it shows how often AI names your shop and who it names instead. See what that looks like in the sample report at spilld.ai.

Sources

  1. BrightLocal, "What 200k local AI searches tell us about what businesses get recommended, and why your website matters" (Mike Hawkes, Sept 16, 2026)
  2. SOCi, "2026 Local Visibility Index", as reported by Localogy (Mike Boland, Jan 28, 2026)

See what AI says about a shop like yours.